I truly enjoyed Michelle's
speech at the DNC last night and thought it was a finely crafted debut to disengaged, undecided, and/or wary voters.
Yet the only reason I responded positively to the speech when I re-read the transcript today was that I remembered Michelle
saying those words, infusing them with passion, warmth, and confidence that leavened the dense sweetness of the written text.
I understand the pragmatic
softening of Michelle's persona, with heavy emphasis on her family-centered life, and the working-class roots. Though she pulls off empathy as beautifully as she does couture, the whole gestalt of the "American story" feels generic and saccharine, and that concerns me.
To be fair, I'm not just referring to Michelle. Sen. Claire McCaskill had the same refrain in her
warmup speech, Michelle's bio video, the whole first night theme involved the relentless repetition of the same phrases- "American dream" "American story" "hard work" et al.- and it felt like Mad Libs, Pollster Edition.
The "American dream" is NOT a reality for many people. I have heard every Democratic candidate in my lifetime before Barack Obama use the same hollow, tired-ass slogans to people who know damn well that the forces that have
concentrated our nation's wealth, or, say,
callously peddle subprime Faustian loans to the working class under the guise of giving them a
foothold into upward mobility - they are a lot stronger than that limp catchphrase.
I believe the Obama candidacy possesses far more substance than the DNC has shown so far, substance of the variety that awakens and empowers people to choose participation in a system that they rightly perceive is broken, and makes us believe that in doing so, we can fix it. Together.
"I'm asking you to believe. Not just in my ability to bring real change in Washington. I'm asking you to believe in yours."In the same way that Obama won over voters in Iowa, lifelong Republicans, inner-city youth, first-time adult voters, our undecided voters need to hear a real, fierce, visceral understanding of how frustrating American life can be right now,
before we get to the part about how great America can be. If you skip straight to the optimism, you've already lost people who have heard this propaganda before, and have no reason to believe that this time those words carry weight.
Good thing we've already made that statement, memorably.
Listen again to
Yes We Can. Pay attention to the moment at 1:58 and 2:29. The music goes into a minor key. You hear the strains of a cello, and later, a mournful violin.
1:58:
"We know the battle ahead will be long." 2:29:
"We have been told we cannot do this by a chorus of cynics. They will only grow louder and more dissonant."and
then at 2:48: "But in the unlikely story that is America, there has never been anything false about hope."
DNC, lose the saccharine-coated Americana marketing. Find your cello.